Log in Subscribe

New priests take on five-church western Sullivan parish

Sean Kuhn
Posted 11/20/26

T

wo priests with very different paths to the priesthood are settling into new assignments serving five Catholic churches across western Sullivan County.

The Rev. Thomas Anthony DeSimone is …

This item is available in full to subscribers.

Please log in to continue

Log in

New priests take on five-church western Sullivan parish

Posted

T

wo priests with very different paths to the priesthood are settling into new assignments serving five Catholic churches across western Sullivan County.

The Rev. Thomas Anthony DeSimone is serving as pastor, joined by the Rev. Thomas Mestriparampil as parochial vicar. Together, they serve Holy Cross in Callicoon, St. Patrick in Long Eddy, St. Mary in Obernburg, St. George in Jeffersonville and St. Francis in Youngsville.

The five churches were brought together under one parish structure last year as part of a broader reorganization of Catholic churches in Sullivan County, prompted in part by declining attendance and fewer priests available to serve the area.

That leaves DeSimone and Mestriparampil responsible for a parish spread across some of the county’s most rural communities, where their work includes celebrating Mass, visiting homebound parishioners, overseeing sacramental life and religious education and maintaining connections among congregations with their own histories and traditions.

Both men arrived at the assignment through markedly different routes.

DeSimone, 62, grew up on Staten Island in a Catholic family. He attended St. Peter’s Boys High School and later studied retail management at Pace University. He spent roughly 15 years working in retail before joining the U.S. Navy, where he served for five years as a weather forecaster.

“I always wanted to be a weather forecaster when I was younger,” DeSimone said, adding that his other early career interest was teaching history.

His life took a different direction while he was in the Navy.

Around October 2000, DeSimone said he began to recognize a calling to the priesthood.

“The Lord put in my heart to go serve him,” he said.

He entered seminary in 2001 and was ordained May 13, 2006, at St. Patrick’s Cathedral in New York City.

DeSimone said priesthood requires a willingness to give up a different kind of life.

“You give up a wife and children for a life that is self-sacrificial, for the sake and love of Jesus Christ,” he said.

His ministry later took him to Kingston, Ellenville and Staten Island, where he also helped care for his mother, now 96.

He learned around the beginning of June that he would become pastor of the western Sullivan parish.

After 20 years as a priest, DeSimone said he was ready for the added responsibility.

The rural assignment has suited him. DeSimone said he enjoys nature, fishing and mountain streams, though his new responsibilities have left him with little time to fish.

He has also had to learn the seasonal rhythm of the parish. While many city churches lose attendance during the summer, he said western Sullivan can experience the opposite as seasonal residents and visitors return.

“They’ve been up here a long time,” DeSimone said.

Mestriparampil’s path to Sullivan County began much farther away.

He grew up in rural Kerala in southern India and was raised in the Syro-Malabar Catholic tradition, one of the Eastern Catholic churches in communion with Rome.

Catholic life was part of his upbringing. He served at the altar and attended church regularly before leaving home at 17 to enter religious formation with the Norbertines.

His studies later took him to Mumbai, Rome and Chicago. He returned to India and was ordained in 1989.

Mestriparampil came back to New York in late 1994 and initially served at Our Lady of Mercy in Port Chester.

But much of his ministry would take place outside a traditional parish setting.

In 1997, he became a chaplain with the New York City Department of Correction, beginning nearly three decades of work with incarcerated people.

Mestriparampil said the ministry centered on listening, counseling and reminding people in prison that they had not been forgotten.

He also remained in contact with some after their release.

“My whole focus in my life has been to serve those who are on the fringes of society,” he said.

That focus extended beyond the correctional system.

Mestriparampil said he spent 16 years serving at St. Charles Borromeo in Harlem, working primarily with Black parishioners, and later ministered to Hispanic Catholics in Manhattan.

He speaks several languages, including Malayalam, Hindi, English and Spanish, with English and Spanish now the languages he uses most often in ministry.

Mestriparampil arrived in Sullivan County in September 2025, first serving in Liberty and later assisting in Woodbourne and Monticello before being assigned to western Sullivan County this September.

Despite spending years in the city, Sullivan County’s rural setting has not felt foreign.

Mestriparampil said the wooded hills and countryside remind him of the region of southern India where he grew up, which he returns to visit each year.

“It resonates with me,” he said. “So I feel at home.”

The geography has also brought some practical adjustments. Mestriparampil said he regularly travels among seven or eight churches when assisting elsewhere in the county, and several weeks ago a deer struck his vehicle, leaving it in the shop.

Still, he said rural ministry gives him more time to reflect.

After 36 years as a priest, Mestriparampil said he still sees himself as learning.

“I don’t have the answer,” he said. “I’m a traveler.”

His advice to younger men considering the priesthood is to see the vocation as extending beyond the walls of the church.

“We need to serve humans, not only those who come to church,” he said, pointing to nursing homes, hospitals, prisons and other places where priests can reach people directly.

DeSimone approaches the assignment with a similar emphasis on personal ministry, though his focus is often on strengthening faith among parishioners and welcoming back Catholics who have fallen away from the church.

“Welcome back,” DeSimone said. “This is part of your family.”

He said those returning would be met with open arms.

“Nobody’s going to scold you. Nobody’s going to yell at you,” he said. “The roof is not going to fall in.”

During a recent Sunday Mass at St. George, DeSimone also urged Catholics not to keep their faith confined to the church building or weaken their convictions simply to avoid discomfort.

He stressed, however, that conviction should not be confused with hostility.

“It’s not about being harsh,” he said. “It’s about being loving, gentle, compassionate, but firmness of conviction.”

Looking ahead, DeSimone said he does not want to judge the success of the parish simply by attendance or collections.

For DeSimone, his hope is “for everybody to fall in love with God more.”

Comments

No comments on this item Please log in to comment by clicking here